The difference between personal accident insurance and health insurance

The role of insurance cannot be overstated. It’s a critical safety net that provides financial protection and peace of mind in the face of unforeseen circumstances. Two types of insurance often cause confusion though: personal accident insurance vs health insurance. While both types of insurance safeguard individuals’ well-being, they differ in their coverage scope, benefits, and suitability for various medical events. Discover more as Bloom provides a greater understanding of the distinctions between these two types of insurance. 

The major differences between personal accident insurance vs health insurance

Who the insurance policy would suit best

Firstly, the difference between accident insurance vs health insurance starts with their definition and who benefits from the policy. 

Personal accident insurance is designed to provide financial protection to individuals in the event of accidents resulting in bodily injury, disability, or death. This insurance typically provides coverage for medical expenses incurred due to accidents, as well as compensation in the form of lump-sum payments for permanent disability or accidental death. Overall, personal accident insurance aims to alleviate the financial burden associated with accidental injuries, offering a safety net for individuals and their families in times of need.

It may also include benefits for temporary disability, such as loss of income due to inability to work. Personal accident insurance is particularly beneficial for individuals engaged in high-risk occupations or activities, such as construction workers, or athletes. The policy can offer peace of mind to anyone concerned about the financial consequences of unexpected accidents. It also provides support to cover certain medical costs and replace lost income during recovery. 

Health insurance, on the other hand, is a type of insurance policy that provides coverage for medical services and healthcare expenses. It aims to alleviate the financial burden associated with healthcare by helping individuals afford quality medical services. It typically includes benefits such as payment or reimbursement for doctor visits, hospitalisation, prescription medications, diagnostic tests, surgeries, and other medical treatments. The exact scope of coverage will depend on the type of health insurance plan. 

Health insurance is suitable for a wide range of individuals, including families, individuals with chronic health conditions, senior citizens, and any individual who is concerned about the high cost of medical expenses. Families benefit from health insurance by ensuring access to quality healthcare for themselves and their children without facing a financial burden. Individuals with chronic health conditions rely on health insurance to manage ongoing medical needs and afford treatment plans. 

Moreover, health insurance provides financial security to individuals by addressing the risk of medical emergencies, like a car accident, or illnesses, like having a stroke or heart attack, that could lead to substantial medical bills. 

Cover comparison between accident insurance vs health insurance

Personal accident insurance focuses on providing financial protection in the event of accidental injuries resulting in bodily harm, disability, or death. It typically covers expenses directly related to these accidents, such as on-site emergency medical treatment, hospitalisation, and rehabilitation. Additionally, personal accident insurance often includes benefits like lump-sum payments for temporary or permanent disability or even accidental death, as well as compensation for lost income.

While personal accident insurance provides coverage for injuries resulting from accidents, it has limitations compared to health insurance. Personal accident insurance typically does not cover medical expenses related to an illness or pre-existing condition, like cancer or diabetes. Nor does it provide comprehensive coverage for preventive care or ongoing healthcare needs.

Health insurance offers a broader spectrum of coverage, encompassing not only accidents and emergencies but also treatment for illnesses, preventive care, medication and other various medical services, like access to specialists. Health insurance policies typically cover a wide range of healthcare expenses, including prescription medications, diagnostic tests, surgeries, and hospitalisation. 

Moreover, many health insurance plans include benefits for preventive care services like vaccinations, healthcare screenings, check-ups and wellness programmes aimed at maintaining health and detecting potential health issues early. Health insurance offers comprehensive coverage for both accidents and illnesses. It provides financial protection against a broader range of medical expenses and ensures access to healthcare services for overall well-being and health. 

Scope of benefits

Personal accident insurance primarily offers benefits tailored to accidents, such as a lump-sum payout for an accidental disability or death. While these benefits provide financial support in the aftermath of accidents, it does not extend coverage to medical expenses related to illnesses, preventive care, or chronic disease management.

For instance, imagine a construction worker named John who sustains a severe back injury while working on a project. His personal accident insurance policy kicks in, providing a lump-sum payout to cover his medical expenses and compensate for his loss of income during his recovery. However, after his recovery, John develops diabetes, which requires ongoing medical treatment and medication. In this instance, his personal accident insurance offers no assistance as coverage does not extend to chronic diseases or conditions. Without the necessary insurance, John would have to pay for medical services out-of-pocket.  

Health insurance, in contrast, provides a comprehensive range of benefits that includes preventive care, prescription drugs, and management of chronic illnesses. It provides access to a broad spectrum of medical services, including regular check-ups, screenings, vaccinations, and treatments for acute and chronic conditions. Health insurance plans often offer flexibility in benefits and coverage options, allowing individuals to tailor their insurance to suit their specific healthcare needs and preferences. This flexibility lets individuals choose coverage that suits both their health needs and budget.

Consider Mbali, a young professional covered by health insurance. She regularly visits her GP for routine check-ups and screenings, ensuring early detection of any health issues. When she develops high blood pressure, her health insurance covers the cost of medications and specialist consultations. Later, when Mbali decides to start a family, her health insurance extends coverage to prenatal care, delivery expenses, and paediatric services for her baby. This comprehensive coverage not only addresses her current healthcare needs but also adapts to life’s evolving circumstances.

Premiums and costs: personal accident insurance vs health insurance

Personal accident cover typically features lower premiums compared to health insurance due to its narrower scope of coverage. Premiums for personal accident insurance are often based on factors like the policyholder’s age and coverage amount. While premiums may be lower, personal accident insurance policies usually have higher deductibles and more out-of-pocket expenses than health insurance. 

Health insurance premiums tend to be higher due to the comprehensive coverage it offers for a wider range of medical services. In addition, there are different health insurance plans from which to choose, which will vary in cost depending on the coverage level. Health insurance typically includes lower deductibles and fewer out-of-pocket expenses compared to personal accident insurance, which means it provides more extensive financial protection against healthcare costs.

Choosing between personal accident insurance vs health insurance

Ultimately, the choice between personal accident insurance and health insurance depends on individual needs, risk factors, and budget. For individuals in high-risk occupations or those who engage in activities prone to accidents, personal accident insurance may offer essential protection against unforeseen injuries. However, for comprehensive medical coverage of both accidents and illnesses, health insurance is a good choice. 

Get health insurance for quality medical services.

While personal accident insurance and health insurance both play vital roles in protecting your health and well-being, they serve different purposes and offer different levels of coverage. Personal accident insurance essentially provides financial support in the event of accidents or disability. Health insurance offers comprehensive medical cover, spanning preventive care, chronic illness management, and a broad range of medical services.

Make an informed decision about your healthcare cover by contacting our offices to speak to a trained consultant about our range of health insurance plans

Your journey to quality healthcare starts here.

Health Insurance

Health4Me Bronze

Health4Me Silver

Health4Me Gold

Gap Cover

Gap Core

Gap Max


About Bloom

Frequently Asked Questions


Contact Us

Momentum Health4Me is not a medical scheme product, and is not a substitute for medical scheme membership. The information provided on this website does not constitute advice in terms of the Financial Advisory and Intermediary Services Act. Momentum is a division of Momentum Metropolitan Life Limited, an authorised financial services provider (FSP 6406) and a wholly owned subsidiary of Momentum Metropolitan Holdings Limited.

Bloom Gap Cover is not a medical Scheme. Products that are offered are not the same as that of a medical scheme.

© Bloom Financial Services 2023. Bloom Financial Services (Pty) Ltd is an authorised financial services provider (FSP 50140). Bloom Gap is underwritten by Infiniti Insurance Limited a licensed non-life insurer and an authorised financial services provider (FSP No.35914)

Privacy Policy